How I Picked My Book's Genre (After Almost Writing the Wrong One)
When I started writing, I didn't actually sit down and choose a genre first. I just started writing scenes that interested me, and it wasn't until I was a few chapters in that I realized I was accidentally mixing three different genres at once, and none of them were working together.
1. I was writing for myself, not for a reader
My early drafts had elements of mystery, light fantasy, and literary fiction all mixed in. It felt creative at the time, but in hindsight, I wasn't thinking about who would actually want to read this book. Looking back, exploring a custom fiction book writing service at that stage might have helped me spot the genre confusion much earlier instead of three chapters in.
2. I started reading like a writer, not a fan
Once I noticed the problem, I went back and reread ten or so books in the genre I was leaning toward. Not for enjoyment this time, but to study pacing, tone, and structure. That's when I realized my instincts were closer to mystery than fantasy, even though the fantasy elements felt more fun to write.
3. I had to cut scenes I liked
This was the hardest part. Some of my favorite chapters didn't belong once I committed to a genre. I kept a separate file of the cut material instead of deleting it, which made it easier to let go without feeling like the work was wasted.
4. I rewrote with a clearer lens
Once I had a genre locked in, revising got noticeably easier. I stopped second-guessing tone and started making decisions faster, because I finally had a filter for what belonged in the story and what didn't.
5. I got outside opinions before finalizing
Before committing fully, I shared the revised opening chapters with a few people and simply asked what genre they thought it was, without telling them my intention. When their answers matched what I was going for, I knew the shift had worked.
What I'd do differently
I'd figure out genre and audience earlier, ideally before drafting, not three chapters in. It would have saved me a lot of rewriting. I also looked into working with Authors Dream during the editing stage, since having someone experienced help confirm the genre fit gave me more confidence before querying and eventually self-publishing. In hindsight, I'd also plan my low cost book printing budget earlier, since genre changes late in the process can affect page count and cover design costs too.
If you're mid-draft and unsure of your genre
You're not alone, and it's fixable. Read intentionally, ask for honest outside opinions, and don't be afraid to cut what doesn't serve the story you're actually telling.
- Art
- Causes
- Crafts
- Dance
- Drinks
- Film
- Fitness
- Food
- الألعاب
- Gardening
- Health
- الرئيسية
- Literature
- Music
- Networking
- أخرى
- Party
- Religion
- Shopping
- Sports
- Theater
- Wellness